Seven shapes, one normalised score — play where your stars are
The formation is the first choice you make in 38-0, before a single player is drafted, and it is the one people most often assume is hiding an advantage. It is not. The engine normalises every shape so that no formation starts you ahead of another. What the formation does decide is how many slots each line gets — and therefore which positions you will be forced to fill well and which ones you can afford to fill merely adequately.
▶ Pick a formation and draft your XI
There are seven shapes to choose from, and every one of them is eleven slots with exactly one goalkeeper. 4-3-3 gives you three forwards, three midfielders and four defenders. 4-4-2 gives two forwards, four midfielders and four defenders. 3-4-3 keeps three forwards but drops to three at the back with four in midfield. 3-5-2 runs two forwards, five midfielders and three defenders. 5-4-1 goes the other way: one forward, four midfielders and five defenders including two wing-backs.
That leaves 4-2-3-1 and 4-5-1, which are worth a note because in eligibility terms they are the same formation — one forward, five midfielders, four defenders. The difference is where those midfielders sit. 4-2-3-1 splits them into two holding roles and a band of three attacking midfielders; 4-5-1 spreads them as two wide, two central and one advanced. The engine treats a midfielder as a midfielder either way, so choose between them on the pitch layout you find easier to read, not on any expected strength.
Positions are weighted before the season is simulated, and the weights are not equal: the goalkeeper counts most at 1.3, then forwards at 1.2, midfielders at 1.1 and defenders at 1.0. On its own that would make attacking shapes better, since a 3-4-3 would stack more of your XI on heavier slots than a 5-4-1 does. But the weights are normalised across the eleven slots you actually have, so the total always comes to the same thing. A 5-4-1 of a given quality projects the same as a 4-3-3 of that quality.
What survives normalisation is the per-slot share. In a three-forward shape, each forward carries a larger slice of your squad score than each defender does, so one weak forward hurts more than one weak defender. In a five-at-the-back shape the damage from any single poor pick is spread thinner. The engine also applies two gates that ignore formation entirely: a goalkeeper below roughly three-quarters of maximum rating costs you, and one clear passenger anywhere in the XI drags the whole projection down.
Because the formation is locked in at setup and the draft is random, the honest answer to "what is the best formation in 38-0" is the one whose slots you are most confident of filling with high ratings. If you are playing on Hard with ratings hidden and no rerolls, a shape with fewer heavily weighted slots — 4-5-1 or 5-4-1 — is the safer bet, because it concentrates less of your score on the one or two forward slots you may not get to fill well.
On Easy or Normal, where rerolls let you steer the draft, three forwards are easier to justify: the all-time Premier League forward pool is deep, so 4-3-3 and 3-4-3 are realistic. The other lever is the era filter. Lock the draft to the 2000s or 2010s and you narrow the pools you will see, which makes it easier to predict whether your chosen shape is fillable. Pick the formation after you decide how much control you are giving yourself, not before.
Post your run to the leaderboard →
← Back